Currently updated by Bill Andrews, Senior Associate, Bartier Perry (NSW)
Originally authored by David Creais, Executive Lawyer, Bartier Perry (NSW)
Steve White, Principal, White SW Computer Law (Vic)
Currently updated by Roger Wade, Director, WadeLegal (Qld)
Originally authored by Warren Wackerling, Principal, Team Lawyers (Qld)
Currently updated by Eric Ross-Adjie, Principal and Andrea Keri, Principal, Warren Syminton Ralph (WA)
Originally authored by Lorraine Madden, Senior Associate; Maria De Martino, Associate and Parisa De Jonge, Lawyer, Karp Steedman Ross-Adjie, Lawyers (WA)
Andrew Robertson, Partner; Juniper Watson, Associate; Nicola Caon, Lawyer and Ryan Kuss, Clerk, Piper Alderman (SA)
Tim Tierney, Principal, Tierney Law (Tas)
Currently updated by Lyn Bennett, Consultant, Minter Ellison (NT)
Originally authored by Leon Loganathan, Partner and Emma Farnell, Lawyer, Ward Keller Lawyers (NT)
Currently updated by Greg Brackenreg, Partner, Meyer Vandenberg Lawyers (ACT)
Originally authored by Greg Brackenreg, Partner and Jim Hartley, Lawyer, Meyer Vandenberg Lawyers (ACT)
When the nature of a business dispute has been determined the remedy or outcome that is most suited to the problem must be identified. There are a number of remedies available under the law, and it may be appropriate to seek a range of remedies to deal with a single dispute.
Damages
Generally, damages are compensatory in nature. Damages are viewed as a 'substitute' for performance. Consequently, they are designed to put the non-defaulting party in the position they would have been in had the contract been performed.
An award of damages will be made if:
-
there has been a breach of contract;
-
loss or injury has occurred as a result of the breach of contract; and
-
the loss or damage is not too remote from the breach of contract.
See Damages.
Account of profits
An account of profits is a discretionary remedy whereby a party that has been wronged by another party may obtain the profits that the wrongful party has acquired as a result of the wrong committed.
Unlike damages, an account of profits is not designed to put the wronged party in the position in which it would have been if the wrong was not committed. Accordingly, the wronged party does not need to show that it has suffered damage in order to avail itself of the remedy.
Generally a successful wronged party must elect between the remedies of damages or an account of profits.
See Account of profits.
Injunctions
An injunction orders a person to perform an act or restrains a person from committing or continuing to commit a wrongful act. The majority of applications for an injunction seek to restrain.
It is a discretionary remedy, often sought on an urgent interim basis.
See Injunctions.
Specific performance
Specific performance is a remedy for the purpose of compelling a party to perform a contract.
Like all equitable remedies, specific performance is discretionary.
See Specific performance.
Restitution
Restitution is essentially a return to, or restoration of, a previous state or position and an order for restitution requires the defendant to give up his or her gain to the plaintiff.
Originally, restitution was based on implied promise and known as “quasi-contract”. Now it is used to prevent unjust enrichment in defined circumstances. It acts to restore to the rightful owner something that has been unjustly taken away, lost, or surrendered.
See Restitution.
Declarations
A declaratory judgment is a formal statement by a court confirming the existence or non-existence of a state of affairs. A party in proceedings may seek an order that the court declare the existence of a right or obligation of itself or of another party. It is not a creation of rights, but an indication of what rights already exist.
See Declarations.
Liquidated sum claims
A liquidated debt is an amount which can be ascertained by calculation or fixed by a scale of charges, or other positive data. By comparison, damages that are not mathematically calculable and which are therefore uncertain and subject to assessment are categorised as unliquidated damages.
Claims for liquidated damages include claims for debts, remuneration, quantum meruit claims, and claims for breach of a contract in which the amount of damages is specified, or can be calculated.
See Liquidated sum claims.
Solvent and insolvent dissolution and distribution
This group of remedies is appropriate for the dissolution or termination of businesses, and/or the structure under which a business is being conducted. Differing principles apply according to whether the business is being conducted by a natural person or persons, or by a legal structure, and according to whether the business and in the case of a structure, the structure itself, is or is not solvent.
See Solvent and insolvent dissolution and distribution.
Possession
Outside the area of landlord and tenant, the remedy of possession of land generally arises in circumstances where a mortgagee seeks to enforce a legal (or registered) mortgage.
See Possession.
Corrective orders
Corrective orders can be made by the courts in a number of contexts, and for a number of purposes including rectification of wrongly drafted documents that do not reflect the intentions of the parties, correction of misleading statements and advertising, and restoring records of shareholding wrongly omitted or removed from a share register.
See Corrective orders.